W

09-13-1958

25

San Diego Marines (CA)

19

Flagstaff, AZ

W

09-20-1958

16

Cal Poly-Pomona

8

Claremont, CA

W

09-27-1958

13

McMurry (TX)

6

Flagstaff, AZ

W

10-04-1958

28

Redlands (CA)

14

Redlands, CA

W

10-11-1958

37

La Verne (CA)

0

Flagstaff, AZ

W

10-18-1958

20

New Mexico Highlands

0

Flagstaff, AZ

W

10-25-1958

41

Oklahoma Panhandle St.

7

Flagstaff, AZ

W

11-01-1958

30

Western New Mexico

7

Silver City, NM

W

11-15-1958

7

Willamette (OR)

0

Yuma, AZ

W

11-22-1958

40

Cal St.-Chico

6

Chico, CA

W

12-06-1958

41

Gustavus Adolphus (MN)

12

Tucson, AZ

NAIA Semifinal Playoff Game

L

12-20-1958

13

Northeastern St. (OK)

19

Saint Petersburg, FL

Holiday Bowl (2) - NAIA Championship Game