W

09-05-2009

14

John Carroll (OH)

7

University Heights, OH

W

09-19-2009

47

Waynesburg (PA)

24

Crestview Hills, KY

W

09-26-2009

34

Westminster (PA)

16

New Wilmington, PA

W

10-03-2009

40

Bethany (WV)

12

Crestview Hills, KY

W

10-10-2009

40

Saint Vincent's (PA)

13

Latrobe, PA

W

10-17-2009

17

Grove City (PA)

7

Crestview Hills, KY

W

10-24-2009

28

Thiel (PA)

14

Greenville, PA

W

10-31-2009

14

Washington & Jefferson (PA)

7

Washington, PA

W

11-07-2009

21

Geneva (PA)

12

Crestview Hills, KY

W

11-14-2009

42

Mount Saint Joseph (OH)

17

Cincinnati, OH

W

11-21-2009

49

DePauw (IN)

39

Crestview Hills, KY

Division III 1st Round Playoff Game

L

11-28-2009

29

Johns Hopkins (MD)

31

Crestview Hills, KY

Division III 2nd Round Playoff Game